Jim Somerville AM - gentle and persistent campaigner for the environment 12 July 1915 to 21 May 2014
Jim Somerville AM - gentle and persistent campaigner for the environment
12 July 1915 to 21 May 2014
I met Jim (James Graham) Somerville in the 1970s. I was near the start of my working life and Jim was near the end of his.
We were members of the Colong Committee. Jim had been there for the successful campaign to stop limestone mining at Mount Armour and the Colong Caves in the 1960s.
I had joined some years after when the big issues were saving Lake Pedder from the Tasmanian Hydro-Electric Commission and stopping the NSW Forestry Commission from clearing the native forest of the Boyd Plateau for a vast pine plantation (Pedder was lost but we won the Boyd fight).
Milo Dunphy was the big man in the Colong Committee in those days. We were all in awe of Milo. He looked and talked like a militant environmentalist.
When Jim Somerville returned to an active role in the Committee about 1974 I hardly gave him a second look. He didn't look like a militant anything.
But that was Jim's advantage. Inconspicuous, good-natured, a non-threatening figure, he could operate below the radar. He went places where the rest of us didn't go. He met and talked to people that Milo would have scared away. With his intellect and gentle persistence Jim achieved much.
I noticed that Milo deferred to Jim in many things and I had to revise my initial impressions when one day I went to Jim's place of work to collect some papers. The large and well-situated office he occupied in the Qantas building in Chifley Square flagged him as an important man.
Although his responsibilities at Qantas had been considerable, Jim was a relaxed and genial character. He was always ready to laugh. In fact he liked a bit of mischief. I remember the delight he took in recounting a phone call where he passed himself off as someone else in order to confound the 'enemy'.
After I was appointed Executive Officer of the National Parks Association in 1974, I worked with Jim on many issues and our friendship grew.
I recall going with Jim and Milo to talk to Neville Wran. It was our first meeting with the Opposition Leader and it took place at his Parliament House office. When we were ushered in I remember thinking it was a very small room. It seemed just big enough for a desk and few chairs.
Miraculously, Neville Wran managed to make a highly theatrical entry from the back. Even more unexpected was his friendly manner and his interest in our concerns. It was clear from the discussion afterwards that Jim and Milo expected a lot from a future Wran Government, and they would not be disappointed.
Wran would soon marry Jill Hickson, a colleague of Jim's at Qantas; this would prove to be a valuable connection.
Jim's interest in the politics of nature conservation began with bushwalking. He was a member of the Coast and Mountain Walkers from 1936, and in 1944 he was appointed as the bushwalkers' representative on the Trust of the Heathcote Primitive Area south of Sydney, now Heathcote National Park. He served on the Trust alongside Milo's father, Myles Dunphy.
In 1968 Jim attended the inaugural meeting of the Colong Committee, formed to stop a subsidiary of the world's largest cement company, Blue Circle, from quarrying 50 million tons of limestone in the southern Blue Mountains. The Committee won that argument after a seven-year struggle. As mentioned, it then went on to scuttle the NSW Forestry Commission's plans on the Boyd Plateau.
After that, Jim set his sights on saving the remaining big areas of rainforest in New South Wales. This was a major interest of mine at the National Parks Association. It was while working with Jim on the rainforests that I got to know him well.
I need not say a lot about this period as Jim has left us his account entitled 'Saving the Rainforest'. It runs to more than 170 pages, although characteristically he underrates his own contribution. He was prominent in efforts to save rainforest areas at Levers Plateau and Gradys Creek in the Border Ranges, and at Terania Creek.
In addition to the Colong Committee, Jim gave other environmental groups the benefit of his time and expertise over long periods, notably the National Parks Association and the Nature Conservation Council.
Around the mid 1980s Jim organised a group of residents at Narrabeen to stop the dredging operations then occurring in the Lagoon. I had a law practice and Jim brought his group to me. I ran a five-day case for them in the Land and Environment Court before the Chief Judge, 'Diamond Jim' McClelland.
We called expert evidence to show that although the Lagoon was shallow it did not need dredging to remain usable by recreation craft. Contrary to general wisdom, little of the sand on the bottom was put there by erosion of the surrounding hills; it had come from the sea, deposited in an earlier era when the sea level was higher. Jim Somerville and his group won their case and the dredging stopped, although I don't think the judge put much weight on the scientific evidence I took such pains to present.
Jim Somerville never liked to talk about himself and people could be forgiven for thinking that his many years as an activist extended only to environmental concerns. But his early experience was acquired in another field. In the 1930s Jim was a Christian pacifist. When war came in 1940 his principles were seriously tested. He was directed to report for military registration and refused to take an oath to resist the King's enemies, thereby exposing himself to prosecution and imprisonment.
In spite of the risk, he took an active role in the Sydney Conscientious Objectors Group, an organisation of marginal legality that assisted and advised conscientious objectors and helped to finance their defence in court proceedings. This group no doubt benefited considerably from Jim's strategic insights as well as his administrative and accounting skills. Soon Jim came before a magistrate who refused to accept that his objection to military service was sincere.
Jim lodged an appeal. His case was heard in the District Court in February 1943 by Judge Clancy. Jim told the Court that he had signed the pledge of the Peace Union and was secretary of the Pacifist's Aid Council. He said that if the Japanese came to Australia he would "adopt non-cooperation methods such as Ghandi was adopting in India". The judge decided that Jim was assisting the war effort sufficiently through his service in the Auditor-General's Department and ordered that he be registered for non-combatant duties.
Jim Somerville continued to apply gentle but persistent pressure on the powers-that-be right up to the end of his life. One of the last issues he ran with (but not the last) was the completion of the Narrabeen Lagoon Track.
I know about the very last issue Jim took up because he wrote to me about it a month or so before he died. In the 1970s and 80s he had served on the Board of the State Pollution Control Commission (the predecessor to the EPA), where he mostly pursued nature conservation issues and particularly those involving forests.
One of the reforms to which he contributed was the introduction of tighter regulations on logging of steep slopes. In his letter to me, written in his clear and steady hand, Jim mentioned that the EPA was now backsliding on this issue. Stopping this, he said, would be his "last campaign".
Peter Prineas
Comments
Post a Comment